I'm not really sure this book was what I was exactly "looking for." Granted I did enjoy it, it was not exactly what I was expecting. I was expecting the novel to be just a boring, slow read. It definately was a slow read, but it was not as boring as I expected. I will say, though, that the first four or five chapters were the most boring. I think the book also just took off pretty much right where Tom Sawyer ended. At the beginning, the connection Huck shared with Jim is not something you'd see everyday. To me, it seemed to be just, very, dull sort of relationship. Further into the book, towards the end, it seemed to be a very sharper connection and the relationship seemed to have grown throughout the book, even though it wasn't very blunt.
There were several questions that crossed my mind throughout the book. Some of which include; 1. Does Huck smoke on a regular basis? It seemed to me as though he did, yet he was so young; granted, I know it was a whole different era in time and a whole different culture. 2. In the scene at the beginning where Huck and Tom are creeping around trying not to awake Jim, is Jim outside like on "nightwatch" or something? 3. Does the word 'reckon' have several different meanings as did not really occur in Tom Sawyer? It seemed that these three questions in particular kept crossing my mind at different parts, all throughout the story.
I think this book is a very good, useful example of like in the South at earlier times. I know we often hear and learn about slavery, life in the South, but, I don't think we get to hear it from a young boy's point of view very often. I think Mark Twain does an excellent job of this - he really seems to know how to put things into perspective. To be honest, I did not see this type of writing and level of writing shine through Tom Sawyer. I also didn't see the relationship between Huck and Tom to be the same as it was in Tom Sawyer. It seemed like in Tom Sawyer, Tom was in charge, and here, it seems like Huck is in charge. I am wondering if this has to do with who narrates. I also love how Twain states that those readers who try to seek a moral will be punnished. I don't really remember seeing this in Tom Saywer. It also seems like The Adventures of Tom Sawyer made Huck seem pretty dumb and not very clever. The Adventures of Huck Finn seem to show the exact oppostie. The novel doesn't seem to show that Tom is dumb, but show that Huck is clever and Tom follows. I agree with Mrs. Jesik that Huck does a very good job of staying strong considering everything he endured throughout the book. Thinking about this makes me really begin to feel as I'm in the book right there with them. I have to take a step back and realize that he is a character as well as is his "father."
In general, I gained a new perspective for authors, such as Mark Twain, that I would not read their books on my own time. Before I read this book, I thought these type of authors were just lame and boring. Now, I think they were really trying to get certain points across and they do an excellent job of this. Southern literature used to not interest me one bit, but I think I am starting to get used to the idea and I want to read more books from these types of authors. I look forward to reading the next book so I can compare in my own head the two authors.(:
I thought you did a good job.(: You gave alot of examples and umm I agree with your last post about being a slow read. Mine says exactly the same thing. (:
ReplyDeleteThank you. I'll have to go look at your post.(:
ReplyDeleteI really agree with the way you viewed Huck and Jim's relationship. It seemed, at first, Huck could care less about Jim. The way both he and Tom played tricks on him was just a way to amuse themselves and then get on with their lives. But I think that Jim and Huck had no choice but to connect because of what they were going through together. I think that once Huck saw how much Jim truly cared about him, he took their friendship much more seriously.
ReplyDeleteAlso, I couldn't agree anymore with you than I do on how truely different The Adventures of Tom Sawyer and The Adventures of Huck Finn really are. The Adventures of Tom Sawyer did not amuse me whatsoever. It was the slowest book I've ever read to be honest. I'd keep getting distracted with every little thing and once I set the book down, there was no chance in me picking it back up for a couple of days. However, Huck Finn was much different than that. I loved his actions and everything else.
We gain new perspectives of authors every time we read a new book and I respect you for being able to see that as well. :) Thank you for your comment on my post. :) Looking forward to having you in class.
;morgan.
definitely a slow read!
ReplyDeleteThanks for the comment(:
ReplyDeleteGood post! I hope your peers follow suit.
ReplyDeleteYou are comparing the two novels very much in this post. I think you are right to say that they are very different stories, yet they are written by the same author. Why do you think Twain did this? It is obvious that this book is told from the point of view of Huck, and of course we are going to see immediate differences.
Instead of comparing the books, why don't you look at the main characters/narrators and explore why Twain does what he does. I am interested to see what your repsonse would be. Hmmm... maybe a future paper topic?
Some part of me says Twain did this as maybe showing the two sides of him. For instance, in Tom Sawyer, he revealed possibly a darker side of him. For instance, take the scene where Tom "dies" and goes to his own funeral. This is one of the "darker" scenes. Found in Huck Finn, a much brighter/playful side - although it was kind of dark with the relationship between Huck and Jim. This is definately a question with 100 possible answers.
ReplyDeleteYour last paragraph would definately require a paper for me to respond/explore. It's a possible topic...
I agree with alot you said in this post, Kara! I do have to say something about the slavery in the book. I don't think that it was portrayed at all in Huck Finn. As we learned last year in honors, it was a very tragic thing. In this book, they make it sound like nothing. The questions you asked throughout the book are great and I had them on my mind, also, while reading!
ReplyDeleteI think the book somewhat showed some forms of slavery. The only reason I say this is Huck was not "treated fairly," foresay, but was not treated like dirt. I think this is almost like slavery, only in slavery, people are treated like dirt. I do see where you're coming from, though!(:
ReplyDelete